South Korea Fines Apple $15.5 Million Over App Store Payments and Fees

Oct 28, 2026 439 views

South Korea’s order targets three pressure points in Apple’s App Store business: payment choice, review delays and how commissions are calculated. The Korea Media and Communications Commission (KMCC) fined Apple 20.81 billion won, about $15.5 million, and directed it to revise its policies. Google was also fined over app payment practices.

The order matters because it addresses how the rules work for developers in practice, not just how they’re described. A payment option can exist on paper while remaining unattractive or difficult to use if fees and other conditions discourage developers from offering it. The KMCC’s findings put those conditions, along with the handling of app reviews, under scrutiny.

Payment choice and review delays under scrutiny

The KMCC said Apple and Google effectively steered developers toward their own in-app payment systems by charging a 26% commission and placing additional limits on third-party payment options. The commission and restrictions, it found, made alternatives difficult to use.

That combination is significant. A commission affects the economics of a transaction, while limits on external payment options can affect whether a developer can present a workable alternative at all. Taken together, those rules can shape which payment methods reach users, even when a platform formally permits more than one choice.

Both companies must change their policies to allow external payment methods and address the conditions imposed on developers who use them. That requirement puts the practical details of payment access at the center of the order: the availability of an alternative alone may not be enough if developers still face restrictions.

For developers, the effect will depend on the revised terms. The key questions are whether external payments can be offered in a way that makes commercial sense, what conditions still apply, and whether users can actually choose those methods. Here's the thing: permission on paper doesn’t tell you whether an alternative will be viable in an app.

The commission also faulted Apple and Google’s app review processes. It found that they delayed reviews without giving developers specific reasons, and at times failed to answer questions about the cause of a delay or when a decision could be expected. Both companies are required to revise their review procedures.

Review delays can matter beyond the immediate wait. Developers may need approval before they can release an update or respond to a problem, and a lack of explanation makes it harder to plan around the process. The order doesn’t specify a new review timetable in the material cited here, but it does call for procedures that address the concerns the KMCC identified. Uncertainty is the point.

The KMCC described this as the first enforcement case under South Korea’s 2021 amendment to the Telecommunications Business Act, which established prohibited practices for app market operators, including forcing specific payment methods and unfairly delaying reviews.

That first case gives the decision significance beyond the fines themselves. It shows how the commission is applying the amendment to specific practices involving payment systems and app reviews. (And this is the part most people overlook.) The order’s reach will be judged in part by whether developers see changes in the routine decisions that shape app distribution.

Apple’s commission calculation drew a separate finding

Apple alone faced an additional finding, covering the period from July 2015 through January 2023. The KMCC said the company calculated its 30% commission on different bases for South Korean and overseas developers: it applied the rate to prices including value-added tax (VAT) for South Korean developers, but to prices excluding VAT for developers elsewhere.

The distinction concerns the base on which the percentage was applied, rather than a different headline commission rate. When the same percentage is calculated against different price bases, the amount charged can differ. The commission’s finding focuses on that difference between South Korean developers and developers elsewhere.

The KMCC said the difference amounted to unfairly providing economic benefits for telecommunications services or bundled services on a discriminatory basis compared with other users.

Apple must take steps to prevent that kind of commission treatment from recurring. The order therefore reaches beyond whether developers can select a different payment processor; it also addresses how Apple’s own fees are applied across developer groups.

This is more significant than it looks. Payment choice gets the headline, but fee calculations can influence a developer’s costs even when the developer uses Apple’s own system. If you’re working in this space, the practical question is whether the revised approach makes the calculation consistent and clear across the groups covered by the order.

Apple told Reuters it “disagreed ⁠with the decision and was evaluating options in accordance with South Korean ​laws.” It also said it “has worked with outside developers ​to enable innovation ​through ⁠its App Store.”

That response signals that Apple disputes the decision, while leaving its next steps open. The company’s statement doesn’t resolve the commission’s findings; the concrete test will be how Apple changes its policies and whether those changes address the specific practices cited by the KMCC.

A wider test for App Store policy changes

South Korea’s action lands amid changes to Apple’s app distribution and payment rules in other markets. The company has introduced alternatives in Brazil and Japan, and recently revised its fees and business terms in the European Union.

Those changes provide useful context, but the details cited here don’t establish that the rules are the same across markets. Each set of terms has to be assessed on its own. A change in one region also doesn’t answer whether developers in South Korea will get usable payment alternatives or clearer review procedures under this order.

For developers, the near-term measure will be how the revised Korean rules work in practice: whether third-party payments can operate under usable terms, whether review delays come with clear explanations and timelines, and whether commission calculations treat developers consistently. The KMCC’s full announcement sets out the findings behind the corrective orders.

What this means for you depends on which part of the App Store you rely on. Developers will be watching fees, payment options and the review process; users may notice changes only if developers choose to offer different payment methods or if app updates move through review differently. That said, the order’s importance won’t be measured by its wording alone. It’ll depend on whether the revised policies change those everyday conditions.

What the order will test next

The KMCC has identified specific practices and directed Apple and Google to change policies. The next test is implementation: whether the companies’ revised terms address the restrictions and delays the commission described, and whether developers can understand how those terms apply to them.

There’s a difference between a policy revision and a meaningful change in day-to-day access. Developers will need enough clarity to compare payment options, understand review decisions and anticipate how commissions are calculated. The available details don’t establish how the companies will implement the changes, so those practical results remain open.

South Korea’s case also gives the 2021 amendment a concrete enforcement example. That may make the order relevant to future discussions of app market rules, but the source material here supports a narrower conclusion: the commission has acted on these findings and ordered policy changes. Whether those changes meet the stated concerns will be clearer once the revised procedures are in use.

Worth checking out on Amazon

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and the YouTube channel
Source: Marcus Mendes · 9to5mac.com

Comments

Sign in to comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Related Articles

Apple fined $15.5 million as South Korea orders changes t...