Apple Search Deal Faces Canadian Advertiser Class Action
A Canadian class action will examine whether Google’s payments for default placement on Apple devices discouraged Apple from building a search engine of its own—and whether the arrangement contributed to higher search advertising prices. The certification lets the claims proceed collectively; it doesn’t decide whether Apple did anything unlawful.
That distinction sets the limits of the ruling. At certification, the court considers whether the case can be tried as a class action on a shared set of issues, not whether the plaintiff’s account is ultimately true. The decision keeps a broad dispute alive: what Apple’s agreement with Google meant for competition, and whether advertisers paid more as a result.
The case now centers on Apple
Filed in 2021 by British Columbia event rental company Spark Event Rentals Ltd., the lawsuit initially named Apple and Google. Google was later dropped after a dispute involving an arbitration clause in its advertising contracts, leaving Apple as the sole defendant. That procedural turn leaves the case focused on Apple’s role in the agreement, even though the alleged effects concern Google’s position in search and the prices charged to advertisers.
Apple says its arrangement with Google was a legitimate distribution deal and describes itself as an “innocent bystander.” The plaintiff argues that the companies shared a purpose to restrain competition in search, allowing Google to charge advertisers more than it could in a competitive market. The disagreement turns in part on how to interpret a default placement: as a commercial choice about where users are directed, or as a deal that helped keep a potential rival out of the market.
Justice Thomas found there was enough basis for the case to proceed as a class action, including on the question of whether Google’s revenue-share payments discouraged Apple from developing its own search engine. The proposed class includes Canadian residents who bought Google search ads from 2005 onward, the year Google became Safari’s default search provider under the agreement. For those advertisers, the claim is that the arrangement affected the conditions under which they bought ads, even though they weren’t parties to the agreement between Apple and Google.
This is more significant than it looks: the case asks whether a distribution decision could have consequences well beyond the companies that signed it. But that remains an allegation to be tested. Certification gives advertisers a shared route to pursue it; it doesn’t establish that Apple would have built a search engine or that ad prices were higher because of the deal.
Evidence from the US case informs the claims
The Canadian dispute arrives amid scrutiny of the same deal in other markets. In the United States, testimony from Apple executives Eddy Cue and John Giannandrea featured in the Department of Justice’s antitrust case against Google. A US judge ruled in August 2024 that Google had illegally maintained its online search monopoly through anticompetitive agreements, including its deal with Apple. That ruling supplies a relevant point of comparison, though the Canadian case has its own parties, claims and legal questions.
Justice Thomas referred to testimony from Giannandrea and Cue in assessing whether the Canadian plaintiff had a factual basis for its allegations. He concluded that the material supported an inference that Apple did not compete with Google in search because of their agreement. Inference is doing real work here: the court found enough support to let the claim proceed, not enough to settle what Apple would have done under different terms.
The judge also acknowledged Apple’s objection that the plaintiff had “cherry-picked evidence to support his case.” He said that approach was appropriate at the certification stage, when the court was assessing whether the claims could proceed as a class action rather than deciding their truth. The parties will have to address the evidence in a later phase, where competing explanations can be examined more fully.
“The central proposition raised by these pleadings is that Apple could have used its resources and distribution network to enter the search engine market, but chose not to because Google paid Apple billions of dollars in revenue-share payments to make Google the default search provider on Apple products. This arrangement gave Google market power, enabling it to charge supracompetitive advertising prices on search engines.”
Justice Thomas wrote that the pleadings raised a common purpose to perform an act prohibited by section 45 of the Competition Act, and that it was not “clear and obvious” the plaintiff had failed to plead an agreement between Apple and Google not to compete in search.
Advertiser claims head toward trial
The claim seeks compensation for advertisers who say they overpaid for Google search ads. The court also allowed the question of punitive damages to proceed. No trial date has been announced. The damages questions will depend on whether the plaintiff can establish the alleged conduct and connect it to costs borne by the proposed class.
For advertisers, the case puts a familiar business concern into a different frame: prices can be shaped by market structure as well as by the individual choices buyers make. If you're working in this space, the practical question is whether the evidence can link Apple’s decision not to enter search to the ad prices companies faced. A finding on that point would require more than showing that a large payment changed Apple’s incentives.
What the case could clarify
The certification puts Apple’s role in the search distribution deal under further examination, with advertisers’ alleged costs and the possibility of Apple entering search at the center of the case. Similar disputes often hinge on a difficult counterfactual: what would a company have done if a particular agreement had never existed? Here, that question reaches from Apple’s product strategy to the competitive conditions facing advertisers.
And yet. The ruling hasn’t answered that question, assessed damages or fixed responsibility. The next phase will have to test whether the alleged agreement existed, whether it affected competition, and whether advertisers paid more as a result. The full decision is available from the British Columbia Supreme Court.