Crude Oil Price Elasticity: A Clearer Chart for Gulf Supply Shocks
When oil exports fall, the price effect depends on how much buyers can adjust their demand. A chart that puts Gulf exports and estimated price changes on the main axes makes that relationship easier to inspect—and makes the uncertainty around demand elasticity visible. That’s the central case for a redesign of a widely circulated graphic about potential effects of the US-Iran war on crude markets.
The original diagram, attributed to Haver Analytics, has been used by Robin J. Brooks of the Brookings Institution to illustrate possible oil-price effects. Brooks has generally taken a bearish view of crude prices during the conflict, with the chart helping frame his analysis. One recent example appears in his discussion of Brent at $117. The chart’s underlying point matters: oil demand responds to price, so a supply disruption needn’t translate into an equal-sized price move.
Elasticity turns supply losses into price estimates
Short-term estimates of crude oil’s price elasticity of demand vary, but values around -0.1 to -0.2 are plausible. In the usual explanation, an elasticity of -0.1 means a 1% price increase is associated with a 0.1% decline in quantity demanded. For a supply shock, the same relationship can be read in reverse: if the available quantity falls by 0.1%, the price would need to rise by roughly 1% to bring the market back into balance, assuming demand follows the existing curve.
That approximation gives a sense of the scale involved. At the conflict’s peak, roughly 10% of normal global oil supply was removed from the market. As much as 20% of global supply was exposed to risk, though the author’s assessment is that the actual reduction didn’t reach that level. Using the simple elasticity calculation, a 10% supply cut implies a price increase of about 100% at an elasticity of -0.1, or about 50% at -0.2. The chart is intended to show that range, not to predict a specific market price.
There are limits to this calculation. It applies a linear approximation to a large supply change, and the relationship may not hold precisely across a 10% or 20% shock. It also keeps the demand curve fixed. Over time, income, policy, consumer choices and technology can shift demand; a faster transition to renewable electricity is one possible influence. The exercise also leaves inventory drawdowns out of the calculation, even though existing stocks can cushion a supply loss. These assumptions simplify the picture so readers can compare scenarios.
Why the 3D view obscures the relationship
The original chart combines two quantities—oil exported from the Gulf and the resulting price change—with a third variable: the assumed elasticity. Its perspective plot represents the price increase as a surface rising over exports and elasticity. The data can be useful, but reading values across a three-dimensional surface to three axes takes effort. It’s also difficult to see the overall trend at a glance.
The author recreated the chart in R, using global consumption of 100 million barrels per day, prewar Gulf exports of 20 million barrels per day and a starting oil price of US$72.50 per barrel. The illustrative grid varies exports from 2 to 20 million barrels per day and elasticity from 0.1 to 0.2. It calculates the share of global supply lost from the export reduction, then divides that loss by the assumed elasticity to estimate the percentage price increase. The author notes that the graphic follows Haver in displaying the absolute value of elasticity, without its negative sign.
Color shading improves the recreated perspective plot slightly, but doesn’t address its main weakness. The viewer still has to interpret a raised surface and mentally connect it to several axes. A chart can encode a third variable in height, but that doesn’t mean the extra dimension makes the information easier to use.
A heatmap makes the numbers easier to scan
The first redesign maps the estimated price rise to color in a heatmap. Exports run along the horizontal axis, elasticity along the vertical axis, and each tile represents the calculated price increase for that combination. Selected values are printed inside the tiles, so readers can look up specific scenarios as well as compare the broad pattern.
The heatmap is easier to read than the perspective plot, particularly when the question is “What does this assumption imply?” But its labeled grid starts to resemble a table. That can be useful for precise comparisons, yet it makes the trend less immediate than it could be. The visualization has traded a hard-to-read surface for a tidy set of values, with some loss of visual momentum.
Lines put the main variables in view
The final design makes exports the horizontal axis and estimated price increase the vertical axis. Each line represents a different plausible elasticity. That choice gives the reader a direct view of how the price estimate changes as exports recover or fall, while the spread between lines shows how sensitive the result is to the elasticity assumption.
Color marks each line’s distance from the midpoint of the assumed elasticity range, 0.15. The midpoint line is solid and the others are dashed, making the central case easier to locate. A secondary axis translates percentage increases into implied dollar prices per barrel, based on the US$72.50 prewar reference price. That extra scale helps connect the model’s percentage output to a figure familiar to market readers.
The line chart also supports a practical reading of current conditions. The author suggests Gulf exports might be somewhere between 7 and 15 million barrels per day, while stressing that the actual current level is uncertain. A reader can select an export level, trace upward to the range of lines, and compare the implied price increase with the market price. Any difference may reflect other information, such as inventory levels, expectations about future supply, or demand changes.
On the assumptions shown, the chart suggests that current prices may include some additional price pressure beyond the export-and-elasticity calculation. The author’s interpretation is that markets may be pricing in the possibility that exports could fall quickly from their current, relatively high levels. That’s an inference about risk expectations, not a result directly produced by the supply equation.
Clarity is part of the analysis
The redesign doesn’t settle what crude prices should be, or establish that a particular elasticity is correct. Its value is in making the assumptions and their consequences easier to inspect. The heatmap serves readers who want to compare discrete cases; the line chart better communicates the relationship between export volumes and potential price moves.
That distinction matters when a chart is used to discuss a live market shock. A clean visual can make assumptions appear more certain than they are, especially when the model omits inventory responses and shifts in demand. Here, the range of lines keeps the elasticity uncertainty in view, while the two primary axes make the supply-price relationship legible. The concrete takeaway is simple: put the variables readers need to compare on the axes, and let the uncertain assumptions show up as a range.