Apple Antitrust Case Draws Subpoena Disputes From Epic, Samsung, Oura and Roblox
The discovery battle in the US antitrust case against Apple is widening into a series of disputes over corporate records, executive files and confidential business information. The arguments offer a practical view of what each side hopes to prove: whether Apple’s policies restrict competition, and whether those policies have a sound business basis.
A case built on outside evidence
In March 2024, the Department of Justice, 15 states and the District of Columbia sued Apple, alleging that it limits interoperability with competing products, restricts competition and makes switching devices harder. Apple rejects those claims.
Both sides are now seeking records from companies that compete with Apple or do business with it. Apple has subpoenaed Epic Games, Samsung Electronics America, Meta, Oura, Garmin, Playco, Ultrahuman, PayPal, Match Group and the Connectivity Standards Alliance, among others. The DOJ and state plaintiffs have sought information from Roblox, Epic, Snap and the Connectivity Standards Alliance. Google, Microsoft, JPMorgan Chase and Capital One also appear in court filings.
The evidence could help the parties test how Apple’s rules affect developers, device makers and other businesses. It may also show whether Apple applies its policies consistently and how those policies shape competition.
Companies challenge the requests
Epic Games says Apple’s requests reach too far. Apple is seeking records from three earlier cases—Epic v. Apple in the US, Epic v. Apple in Australia and Epic v. Google in the US—as well as searches of files belonging to three senior executives, including Epic’s CEO. Epic argues that the demands would impose an excessive burden.
Epic has offered to provide several sets of records, including Fortnite user and revenue data, its contracts with Google and Samsung, and documents concerning Apple’s Core Technology Fee.
Samsung says searches of two executives’ files have already produced nearly 900,000 documents matching the parties’ agreed terms. Apple wants searches expanded to six more executives, including current and former CEOs of Samsung Electronics America, and seeks transcripts from Samsung executives who testified in the DOJ’s Google antitrust case. The companies also remain at odds over whether Samsung Electronics America must turn over records held by its South Korean parent, a question covered in an earlier dispute.
Oura is contesting Apple’s demand for more than 32,000 additional documents. The company is also disputing whether Apple should cover the cost of reviewing them and whether Oura can redact or withhold material it considers a trade secret. Garmin has raised comparable concerns about requests for confidential financial and strategic information.
The direction of the subpoena matters in Roblox’s case. Roblox is the only company in the recent filings that was subpoenaed by the DOJ and state plaintiffs rather than by Apple or other plaintiffs. Roblox disputes requests about its relationship with Apple and the way App Store rules are applied. The government says those records could help determine whether Apple treats developers consistently.
Playco raises concerns about policy advocacy records
Japan-based instant gaming company Playco is resisting requests for material about its efforts to influence App Store policies, including lobbying. It argues that producing those records would violate its First Amendment rights and points to a 2021 court decision involving similar requests Apple made to Match Group.
Several companies have asked for until November 11 to continue talks before their disagreements are formally declared at an impasse. That window could resolve some discovery questions without further court intervention.
A separate fight over federal records
The company and the DOJ are also disputing Apple’s effort to obtain documents from 14 federal agencies. A special master has twice ruled in Apple’s favor, but the order is on hold while the court considers the government’s appeal. Together, the disputes show how much of the case’s next phase depends on which outside records the court allows each side to obtain.