UK DeFi Rules Could Cut Regulated Platforms Off From Onchain Markets

Oct 22, 2026 516 views

The gateway question

The UK’s proposed crypto rules could leave regulated platforms unable to connect customers with decentralized finance from October 2027. The practical consequence may be a split market: people can still reach DeFi directly, but firms operating under UK oversight could be barred from offering a managed route in.

That outcome would matter beyond crypto trading. DeFi protocols are part of the infrastructure being used to build onchain financial services, including tokenized markets. If UK firms cannot interact with that infrastructure, they may have less scope to develop products around it, and regulators could lose a useful point of contact for monitoring how customers use it.

The UK has said it wants to “lead the world on digital assets.” That ambition is difficult to square with rules that could prevent authorized firms from connecting customers to the decentralized systems digital asset markets rely on. The policy question is whether consumer safeguards can be applied at the gateway, rather than by excluding that gateway altogether.

Why the proposed rules create a barrier

DeFi lets people borrow, lend and trade through software protocols, without a bank or broker arranging each transaction. It is accessible through open-source networks, where there may be no identifiable operator responsible for receiving regulatory authorization. That structure creates a practical problem for rules designed around identifiable firms and venues.

The Financial Conduct Authority’s proposed framework expects regulated platforms to ensure that customer orders are executed only on an FCA-authorized venue. The stated purpose is to stop overseas firms from accessing the UK market unlawfully. But decentralized protocols and exchanges may not have a person or company that can apply for authorization. Applying the venue requirement to them could therefore prevent regulated platforms from routing customers’ orders to DeFi.

The proposals do not expressly prohibit firms from integrating DeFi services. The concern is how the FCA plans to apply existing rules: it has not proposed a separate framework for these products and instead intends to use requirements designed for centralized trading. A rule can create a prohibition in practice even when it doesn’t use that word.

From Oct. 25, 2027, firms offering crypto services to UK customers will need FCA authorization. The regulator is consulting on guidance for firms whose financial services use or interact with DeFi. The way that guidance treats integrations will help determine whether regulated providers can offer customers a route into these systems.

Consumer risks call for clear boundaries

There are real concerns to address. A customer who starts on a familiar regulated platform may not understand when they have entered an environment with different protections. A firm could also use a DeFi connection to sidestep regulatory duties. And protocols can raise financial crime and market resilience risks.

Those concerns support clear disclosures and defined responsibilities. A platform could tell customers when they are moving outside the regulated service and ask them to confirm before proceeding. It could also limit access to protocols it has assessed, review operational and governance risks, and report relevant incidents and usage to supervisors.

That approach would not make a DeFi protocol equivalent to a regulated venue, or guarantee that a customer is protected from every loss. It would make the transition more visible and give firms responsibilities at the point where they connect customers to the service. The aim should be to make those distinctions understandable before a customer acts.

The UK already allows platforms to offer products with different levels of regulatory protection. Retail trading platforms and “super apps” can provide access to stocks, money market funds, commodities and foreign exchange, provided they explain which protections apply to each product or service. DeFi integrations raise distinct challenges, but the same basic question applies: can a platform make the boundaries clear and manage its role responsibly?

Other markets are exploring access

The UK is not the only jurisdiction working through how traditional finance and DeFi might connect. The European Securities and Markets Authority has proposed allowing regulated firms to provide access to DeFi, saying this could “allow innovation in decentralized finance in a regulated and transparent environment.”

In September, the US Securities and Exchange Commission granted an “Innovation Exemption” for peer-to-peer trading of tokenized stocks using automated trading systems and liquidity pools. These developments reflect efforts to test how established financial services can work with decentralized infrastructure.

The approaches are still taking shape, but they point to a policy choice the UK also has to make. A regulated gateway could give customers more information and give supervisors greater visibility into activity. Closing that route would not remove direct access to DeFi; it could instead leave more customers using services outside the practical reach of regulated UK firms.

What the choice means for onchain finance

Tokenized finance depends on systems being able to interact. If tokenized assets and related services are confined to closed, fragmented networks, they may struggle to connect with the decentralized infrastructure that supports continuous activity across borders. DeFi’s potential cost savings are tied in part to reducing intermediaries and enabling financial services to operate around the clock.

For UK firms, a clear path to responsible integration could offer a basis for developing services and investing in onchain infrastructure. If access through authorized platforms is effectively blocked, companies may have fewer reasons to build those capabilities in the UK, while tokenized markets and related financial technology develop elsewhere.

The FCA’s task is to address the risks without treating exclusion as the only available safeguard. Clear customer disclosures, consent at the point of transition, careful protocol assessment and incident reporting could give platforms concrete duties while preserving a regulated route to DeFi.

DeFi will remain accessible directly, regardless of whether regulated firms can offer it. The decision now is whether UK customers can also reach it through platforms that explain the risks and accept defined responsibilities. That choice will shape how much influence UK firms and supervisors have as financial services move onchain.

Related: UK FCA sets crypto authorization guidance ahead of September application window

Related: ESMA seeks evidence tokenized collateral can be cashed out in crisis

About the author: Katie Harries is the head of policy for Europe at Coinbase. She leads international policy work with regulators, governments and industry stakeholders on digital asset rules in the UK and Europe. Before joining Coinbase, Harries was a vice president at Goldman Sachs. She is also involved in the UK Cryptoasset Business Council.

Magazine: Made an ‘honest’ mistake with crypto taxes? New bill offers way out

Source: FCA

Source: Gov.uk

Editorial Policy

Source: Cointelegraph by Katie Harries · cointelegraph.com

Comments

Sign in to comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Related Articles

The UK needs a workable route to regulated DeFi access